Building Project Updates
LETTER: Amherst Can't Afford to Reject the Jones Library Renovation/Expansion ProjectTerry Johnson’s long piece in the December 8 Gazette suggesting Amherst cannot afford the Jones Library’s renovation/expansion project glosses over two important facts which make it clear that the Town can’t afford to turn it down.
First, the cost of the project to the Town is $16 million, not $22 million. The Library is offering to guarantee that it will raise $6 million of the balance of the total cost of the project, reducing the Town’s share to $16 million. And the Library is willing to back that guarantee with its $8 million endowment.
Second, like it or not, a professional estimate has established that the Town will be required to spend that same amount if the project does not go forward – just to retrofit the building to become code compliant for patrons with disabilities, and to replace the leaking atrium roof, elevator, and HVAC system. For the same amount, Amherst can get a 21st Century Library meeting all of its library needs, and, with recently incorporated state-of-the-art energy conservation measures, advancing the Town’s climate action agenda.
For 30 years, the Town has delayed addressing its major capital construction needs, preferring to study them to death, and leaving future residents to face them all, with millions in additional escalation costs added on. Amherst cannot afford to do that any longer. With the same financing leverage the Library has arranged (allowing the Town to pay less than half the cost of the project), and with careful phasing (the elementary schools project will not come on line for another five years and the fire station and DPW building are nowhere in sight), the Town can meet all its capital needs by starting now instead of kicking the can down the road….again.
Lee Edwards, Trustee and Co-Chair Development Committee for the Friends of the Jones Library
Kent W. Faerber, Co-Chair, Development Committee for the Friends of the Jones Library
This update was published as a column in the Daily Hampshire Gazette on October 22, 2020.
Why It Is Important to Move Forward with the Plan to Renovate and Expand the Jones Library
An update from Austin Sarat and Sharon Sharry
On October 15, the Jones Library Board of Trustees unanimously voted to approve the library’s renovation and expansion plan. The Board also voted to request that the Amherst Town Council approve the plan by the end of April. Those votes were the culmination of more than a decade of careful planning, extensive deliberation and consultation, and continuing commitment to making sure that Amherst’s libraries serve the needs of all its residents.
They point us toward a bright future in which the Jones will continue to nurture democratic values and a vibrant and inclusive culture in our town.
But some might ask, why move forward with the plan now? And why ask for a vote in April?
As to the first question, the Trustees have completed all the work needed to move the plan to fruition. It is now ready for consideration by the people of Amherst and their elected representatives.
Our planning began when the Board of Trustees launched a long-range planning process. As part of that process, we surveyed library patrons and the public. We held focus group sessions and talked with the staff about the library’s needs as well as their own hopes and aspirations.
Those data collection efforts and conversations revealed that, while the Jones was functioning well in many ways, it also had some serious problems and pressing needs. High on that list was the physical condition of the building itself.
Because we wanted to make a great library even better and sustain its greatness into the future, we asked the library director and staff to develop a proposal for improvements, which they did with their usual skill and acumen. That proposal, among other things, called for expanding the children’s room, providing a much-needed teen space, dealing with the inadequacies of our Special Collection and English as a Second Language facilities, and making the building accessible not just for those protected by law, but welcoming for all residents. It became clear that these vital improvements could not be accommodated within the existing facility or in a feasible expansion of the Jones.
So we sent the staff back to the drawing board with a mandate to move from a wish list to a needs list and to establish a clear set of priorities.
When the staff and library director did so, it was apparent that we needed help figuring out how to make this slimmed-down, but still ambitious, program work in our building. To find that help we undertook an architect selection process. We invited proposals and received many, from distinguished firms. After an extensive public vetting of those proposals we chose Finegold, Alexander Architects (FAA), one of the best architectural firms in the state with long experience working with libraries and an outstanding record of historical preservation.
We asked FAA to study whether and how to realize the program within the current building by reorganizing existing spaces and/or expanding within the existing footprint. They showed us that even if we added several stories to the library we still would not be able to do all that needed to be done. They offered alternative suggestions that accommodated the program with a modest expansion of the building.
We created a Feasibility Committee including Trustees, library staff and members of the public to work with FAA and develop a detailed plan for the Jones.
After dozens of public meetings, in January, 2017 we submitted that plan and the proposed program to the Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners as part of an application for a state-funded library construction grant. After our proposal was carefully vetted by experts in libraries and library design, MBLC approved a $13.9 million grant and put Amherst on the waitlist for an appropriation of funds.
Between then and now the Trustees have worked with FAA to further refine the original design. We again have held numerous public meetings and considered and adopted several important suggestions from Amherst residents. We also profited from hearing about the experiences of the numerous neighboring western Massachusetts towns (including Athol, Granby, Greenfield, Holyoke, South Hadley, Hadley, and West Springfield) that have renovated and expanded their libraries.
Along the way, Amherst adopted a net zero bylaw. While the Jones Library was exempt because the project started before the law changed, the Trustees responded to the town’s commitment to sustainability by rethinking the work that had already been done, in an effort to make the renovated and expanded library energy efficient and sustainable. We created a committee of experts and charged them to work with FAA to create a plan that would make the Jones a model of sustainability.
The design the Trustees approved achieves that goal. In addition, it will preserve the library’s historic spaces while being fully accessible to all who wish to use it. It is flexible enough to accommodate anything that needs to be done in Covid-19’s wake, and it rectifies problems that have created serious difficulties for staff and safety issues.
Most importantly, it will serve the needs of Amherst residents for decades to come.
The Trustees decided to ask the Town Council to vote on our proposal by the end of April realizing full well the fiscal challenges that Amherst now faces.
We do so now for multiple reasons, not the least because we expect to be formally awarded the MBLC grant in July, 2021 and because their rules allow towns to move forward in anticipation of state funding. Taking advantage of that funding is a once-in-a-decade opportunity.
We do so because we are convinced that we have a sound and feasible plan for financing the project, which includes a library commitment of $6,000,000 to help offset some of the town’s costs.
We do so because the serious maintenance issues and structural problems which plague the Jones building urgently need to be addressed.
We do so because a detailed study requested by the Town Council of the cost of addressing those issues and problems by repairing the existing building showed that it would cost between $14 and $16 million, which is very close to the amount the town would have to contribute to achieve a renovated, expanded, accessible, and environmentally sustainable Jones Library.
We do so because delay risks both an escalation in costs and a further deterioration of the building.
We do so because children, teens, English language learners, immigrants, disadvantaged people, students of Amherst’s history, families, book lovers and all those who flock to the Jones deserve a facility that is as inspiring as their dreams.
But, most importantly, we do so because, in these dark and dangerous times, we do not want to put the future on hold. A renovated and expanded Jones Library will be a beacon of hope and a reminder that a great town deserves a great library.
We look forward to working closely with the Amherst Town Council as it determines when and how to consider our plan and our request.
Austin Sarat is President of the Jones Library Board of Trustees. Sharon Sharry is the Library Director of the Jones Library.